This is it, the controversial subject that I’ve mentioned for weeks. Sorry for all the suspense. It’s not an easy thing to talk about so I didn’t want to treat it superficially. I’d love to hear comments, but I ask that you be civil and respectful, as you always are.
Other point/counterpoint discussions can be found here, and my original post about these series can be found here. Tune in tomorrow for the counterpoint view.
Point: A practicing Christian can, and sometimes should, vote for a pro-choice candidate.
There are several reasons why Christians should not be so quick to condemn pro-choice candidates for local, state, and national offices. The issue of stopping abortion has been so associated with Christianity in recent times that it can be hard to seperate the faith from the issue, but it is necessary to do so.
First of all, Christians limit their potential impact on an election if they simply choose a pro-life candidate for that reason exclusively, regardless of the other issues. This is further compounded when they exclusively vote along party lines. Neither political party corresponds directly to Christian values as laid out in the Bible.
A major point to consider is that while Christians should not be pro-abortion, they must realize that God judges morality, not the state. We shouldn’t expect or want a government body that regulates morality. This means that the Christian should not be willing to have an abortion herself but should allow others to stand before God for their choices rather than judge them here on earth. It is a matter of personal choice, but that does not mean that choosing to have an abortion and choosing not to have an abortion carry the same moral value before God.
This means that rather than focusing so much time on issues like abortion and gay marriage, Christians should fight for other issues that are also thoroughly biblical like justice and helping the poor. In these things they can be like the one they claim to follow, Jesus Christ. If Christians spend too much time fighting against abortions and changes to the understanding of marriage, they will neglect the serious issues that Jesus attended to.
For these reasons, a Christian should judge a candidate not exclusively on the issue of abortion, but take the candidate as a whole. There can and will be times where the pro-choice candidate will be the proper and more Christian choice.
The counterpoint and second post on this subject can be found here.
