For Illegal Immigration? (re-post)

On my near-hour commutes to and from the office, I like to listen to talk radio. I don’t feel compelled to agree with the talk show hosts (usually locals Brad and Britt in the morning and Sean Hannity in the evenings), but enjoy hearing opinions that may or may not mesh with my own. The latest hot topic has been immigration. This is a topic that I struggle to come to an actual opinion on, because there are two competing desires within me.

The problem I have with the majority of anti-immigration advocates is that there are often strong nationalist, xenophobic, and ethnocentric underpinnings to this stance. Yes, there are legitimate concerns with national security and law enforcement that come in to play, but all too often I hear people complaining about the increasing cultural diversity as if America has always been static and English is the only language that should be spoken in a civilized country.

As a Christian, I worship a God that is calling all peoples to Himself. America is not the new Israel, a nation chosen by God in some special way. Yes, God has blessed America, and I am incredibly thankful to have been born here. However, my citizenship is ultimately in heaven and that is where my true allegiance lies. This influences how I view American foreign policy.

I’m excited to live in a place where the nations are coming to us. The American church has the blessing of being able to reach out to individuals who come from places where they would never have heard the Gospel. I never want to be a part of a local church that does not welcome “outsiders” whether openly or by simply by ignoring them.

I generally agree with the ideas I’ve heard about the latest immigration bill, but I’m not willing to support it outright without knowing the details. While I don’t like the fact that there is a huge number of immigrants who have entered our country by breaking the laws, I’m not going to push them out. They are no more or less important than anyone else.

The issue of immigration is where my love of rule-following and my love of all people come at odds with each other, but I’m okay with that. I know which one will come out on top.

Originally posted 5/18/2007

Can I Add a Moderate Voice to This Word Fight?

I feel compelled to speak up on a controversial issue, one I usually would have the smarts to stay out of. But so much rage has been filling my Twitter feed that I can’t stay silent.

I just can’t believe that people are all up in arms about Limbaugh’s “slut” comment.

Not because what he said wasn’t insensitive; it was. But have these people that are so angry at Rush ever listened to his show? He makes his bread and butter by being insensitive and spewing barb-filled rhetoric. There’s just not anything particularly special about these latest comments that, in mind is more (or less!) insensitive and unhelpful.

Now that we’ve opened the can of worms, what are my thoughts?

Well, I am a single woman that has used birth control for medical reasons. I actually know many women that are prescribed birth control for therapeutic reasons, not because they’re necessarily using it to prevent pregnancy.

When I was first prescribed these pills, I was shocked at how expensive they were with my insurance. I could get a month’s worth of each of my other prescriptions for $10 or less, but my birth control would have been $35 a month (for 24 pills) if I hadn’t had a coupon lowering it to $24. Which, with the excellent insurance coverage I had at the time, still seemed high for a fairly routine medication.

I don’t know why they are so expensive after insurance. I can only assume that they were treated differently by my insurance company because they’re not seen has medically necessary, even when they are. Was I prescribed these pills because I was a “slut”? Of course not.

I would love for my insurance to have to cover these pills at least to the same level they cover my other medications, if only for a selfish, money-saving reason.

But, do I think that religious institutions that take issue with the use of birth control be required to pay for it for their employees? Absolutely not.

I personally have a problem with using birth control pills as birth control. If I were married (and thus sexually active), I would work with my doctor to get off of birth control pills or use an alternative birth control method to prevent the pills from having any possible abortive effect.

So, yes, I understand why a religious institution with similar beliefs would not want to fund birth control pills. I believe that this is perfectly within their rights as a religious institution in this country. They are not preventing their employees from using birth control, only declining to subsidize its use.

“Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof,” is a right guaranteed by our constitution. Having someone else pay for your health care, is not. When you go to work for a place, you can’t expect that they will condone or support your choices when they do not align with their beliefs.

At this point, you might wonder why I’m asserting that I have a “moderate voice.” Perhaps I do lean a little bit to the right, and I’m okay with being accused of doing so. But here is what I have to say to Rush Limbaugh and his type: stop calling names. No argument, from the playground to the Supreme Court, has ever been won by calling the other person names. A civil, reasonable discussion will never happen if we resort to name calling and raising our voices.

Of course, the same First Amendment that guarantees the free expression of religion also gives you freedom of speech. So go ahead. But just don’t be surprised if we ignore you as irrelevant and unhelpful.

Book Review: Return to Sender by Julia Alvarez

Return to Sender is actually my second Julia Alvarez title, as I had read A Time for Butterflies a few months ago for book club. I wasn’t too happy with A Time with Butterflies as I don’t like it when authors make something historical fictional…I want to know what is factual and what was imagined! I’m glad I didn’t allow that to keep me from listening to this book!

Return to Sender is the story of two preteens in Vermont, Tyler and Mari, who are thrown together in less-than-ideal circumstances. Tyler’s father has had an accident, and is no longer able to do to the hard physical labor that being a dairy farmer requires. The rest of the family isn’t able to keep up with the work, so the only options they have is to hire help or lose the farm.

Mari’s father and 2 uncles are the help that is hired.  They need any job they can get and are happy to help, given their background in farming in Mexico. Unforunately, Mari’s mother has been separated from their family, missing for 8 months since she visited her mother in Mexico. Mari and her family have no idea where she is or how to contact her, and are understandably worried as they know that she should have been back by now.

Return to Sender tells the story from the point of view of Tyler, with Mari’s letters and journal entries thrown in. I love how it shows a bit of what it’d be like to be on both sides of the issue of illegal immigration.

This is a great book to read with your middle schooler as a conversation starter on this topic, regardless of where you stand on the issue. It’s great strength–beyond being simply well-written–is that it puts human faces and emotions to a political discussion which so often become a screaming match.

Disclosure: I did receive a free audiobook of this title for review for AudioFile magazine, but no compensation for this review. I liked it so much that I wanted to offer a review of it on my blog as well!

Book Review: Extraordinary, Ordinary People by Condoleezza Rice

I found this book when I was searching what ebooks my library had available.  I hadn’t even heard of it before, though it came out earlier this fall.  Since I enjoy memoirs and was curious about Condoleezza Rice’s background, so this was an easy choice for me.

I’m glad that they had it, as I really enjoyed it (obviously, as it made my top books of 2010 list).  Regardless of where you stand politically, I think you can still like this book…it is not a political memoir.  I think Rice intentionally framed it around her parents so she had an excuse to end before she joined George W. Bush’s staff (her father dies in 2000).

Rice grew up in the South, but her story of growing up black in the 60s South is not like anything I’ve read before.  While she definitely still had obstacles to overcome, her family was well enough off (and her parents made many sacrifices for her, their only child) that she had many more opportunities than you might expect.

If there was only one thing I learned about Rice, it’s that she is incredibly driven.  Her parents certainly pushed her early–even attempted getting her in first grade when she was 3 (she stubbornly refused to stay)–but they weren’t the only ones pushing her. Her family later moves to Denver so that she could continue to pursue figure skating year round (believe it or not, there were no skating rinks in Birmingham), though she herself admits she was not built for the jumps.  She also is an excellent pianist thanks to her drive (and presumably her natural talent as well).

Rice was chosen to be the provost of Standford University at the age of 38, becoming the youngest, first minority, and first woman to hold that position.  She does a good job of showing why she rose to the top so quickly, not because she toots her own horn, but because she clearly has a dynamic personality that accompanies her drive for excellence.

As a fellow single woman, I appreciate stories like this.  While she would have loved to have been married, she recognized that a husband is a prize for the worthy and that singlehood is better than marriage to the wrong person.

I definitely recommend this book to anyone who enjoys a good memoir.

27 Things at 27

Continuing the birthday-eve tradition of 26 things and 25 things, here are 27 things that I’ve done at the age of 27:

1.  Saw Phantom of the Opera.

2.  Saw my baby brother marry the best woman for him.

3.  Was a bridesmaid (and a maid of honor) for the first time(s).

4.  Got buried in snow in North Carolina for the first time.

5.  Watched Gone with the Wind.

6.  Added a second tax site at work.

7.  Met a US congressman…who got voted out in the most recent election.

8.  Read several books that really influenced me.

9.  Started making serious progress on making my life better for creation.

10.  Saved a (very small) emergency savings, and kept it.

11.  Left apartment life behind (though I was sad to part ways with my roommate of 3 years).

12.  Grew my first vegetable garden with moderate success.

13.  Went on my first overnight work trip.

14.  Got my car wrecked by an anonymous drunk, angry driver.

15.  Went to kids’ camp for the first time as an adult and loved it.

16.  Have finished my 5th year at my job…by far the longest I’ve worked anywhere.

17.  Helped my roommate through the first homeowner’s crisis I’ve ever dealt with: the death of a water heater.

18.  Vlogged for the first time.

19.  Got my game on, competing with friends in a diet and exercise competition.  The first time was helpful, the second time, not so much.

20.  Switched from teaching Sunday school to kindergarteners to helping with the 5th and 6th grade class.

21.  Had my first solo vacation and loved it.

22.  Voted for my first Democrats.

23.  Helped with the first ever Readathon for Hunger.

24.  Wrote a novel.

25.  Decorated my first full-sized Christmas tree not in my parents’ home.

26.  Read 164 books.

27.  Traveled to Atlanta, Wichita, Myrtle Beach, Norman, Charlotte, Roanoke, Denison (Texas, 2x), Kansas City, small town Kansas, and the middle of nowhere.

At Least Do It for the Sticker

I can’t believe it’s Election Day again.  It feels like it was just Election Day 2008…am I the only one who thinks that?

I actually haven’t been following politics as closely as I used to.  It seems like it’s all the same old debates, and no one in politics really seems to see things like I see them.  That’s okay…just means that I have to spend a lot of time researching, thinking, and praying over whom to vote for.

Regardless, I’ll be voting today.  If you’re a US citizen 18 and older, you better be too (unless, of course, you voted early).  No one can speak for you like you can speak for yourself, so don’t remain silent.

I may not be very patriotic, but voting is one of my favorite parts of being an American.

Photo by Jessica Whittle Photography

Book Review: Dirty Sexy Politics by Meghan McCain

Though I’ve read very little by Meghan McCain before, I knew I wanted to read her book from the first time I heard of it.  Why?  Because she is a fresh voice, not toeing the party line.

Actually, today she is still making headlines as a “rebel.”   So what if she chose to take a break from publicizing her book?

Sadly, she also gets flack for her weight.  Seriously?  Aren’t we past judging others based on how they look? (Don’t answer that…I know that we’re not.)

Dirty Sexy Politics is Meghan’s story of working on her father’s 2008 campaign for almost 2 years.  She had just graduated from college when she joined, and this was very much a coming-of-age time for her.  She learns a lot…often the hard way.

I’m no longer a Republican because I no longer feel like that party (or any other out there) represents my views.  Meghan has just as many problems with the current state of the Republican party, but she’s trying to change it from within it, which I can respect.

That said, we don’t see eye-to-eye on every issue.  But I do believe that we’d have a great discussion if we sat down to talk.  I watched a book talk she did a few weeks ago that was aired on C-SPAN.  She’s a great writer, but doesn’t come off as articulate and intelligent  in person.  Neither do I.

Politics needs more people like Meghan.  Our generation needs to speak up, not just to vote for the cool candidate, but to share our views on the issues.  This country is broken and it needs us if it’s ever going to be fixed.

I found the book interesting and hard to put down, but perhaps there’s not enough here to make it recommendable.  If it sounds interesting, though, pick it up!

Oh, and I LOVE the back cover (photo on right)…she’s definitely gotten hosed by those in AND out of the Republican party!

Church Quotes

“You could always count on Mrs. Mohler to keep the gossip flowing, using church words to make it okay.” – Daisy Chain by Mary DeMuth, p. 139

“Faith is a lack of contentment with what I am, but a sense of satisfaction with what God has given me of himself in Jesus.” - Mere Churchianity by Michael Spencer, p. 146

“For if anyone thinks he is something when he is nothing, he deceives himself.” – Galatians 6:1, NASU

about the Republican Party, but sadly, it describes a lot of churches, too: ”You have to look one way, think one way, and act one way.  Wear the uniform!  Embrace groupthink!  And for goodness’ sake, no strangers allowed!…The doors and windows aren’t just shut.  The curtains are drawn.” - Dirty Sexy Politics by Meghan McCain, p. 8

“There is little need for large churches stuffed with satisfied audiences.  There is a great need for a movement of disciples going into the overlooked places of the world to see and serve the kingdom of God.” - Mere Churchianity by Michael Spencer, p. 101

“They killed anyone who stood in their way.  They burned our house down and called it a mistake.  They weren’t in their own country so they didn’t have to answer to anyone.” - In the Time of Butterflies by Julia Alvarez, p. 57

“Jesus’ assignment to the apostles was not to get people to respond to an altar call but to make disciples of all nations.” - Mere Churchianity by Michael Spencer, p. 99

“But lately, in the Republican Party, anybody with a new idea is labeled ‘progressive,’ that dirty word, or just ignored.  I can’t think of a greater turn-off.  Why would a vibrant young person, full of energy and passion and lots of creativity, be interested in the Republican Party if new ideas and fresh starts aren’t welcome?” - Dirty Sexy Politics by Meghan McCain, p. 38

“In the last century, evangelical Christians parted ways with Christians in mainline churches, in part over suspicions about ‘the social gospel.’  Evangelicals came off sounding as if helping people was borderline unbiblical.” - Mere Christianity by Michael Spencer, p. 203

“The country people around the farm say that until the nail is hit, it doesn’t believe in the hammer.” – In the Time of Butterflies by Julia Alvarez, p. 20

“If a church isn’t supporting and growing disciples, isn’t crossing cultures with the gospel, and isn’t encouraging and producing Jesus-followers, I believe you’re entitled to look for a different form of community that is doing these things.” – Mere Churchianity by Michael Spencer, p. 212

Blind Spot

I’ve been thinking for a while about my step back from party politics.  I think that giving up their heart to the Republican Party en masse was one major downfall of the older generation of Evangelical Christianity.

While I do believe that our spiritual views should influence how we vote and what political candidates we support, I think we’re foolish if we think any party (unless it’s explicitly based on the Bible…then maybe) is going to have the same beliefs and priorities that we do.

I know I’m not the only one who has recognized this, and I’m glad that more and more people in my generation are picking up on this.  I can’t wait until we can say together, “We are followers of Christ, not of the Republican Party.  We are not them.”

I don’t intend to bash the GOP (they’re not better or worse than the Democrats), but there is a reason why politics get a bad name.  And by saying that to be a Christian is to be a Republican, we’re dragging Christ’s name through the mud, too.

While I’d love us to get beyond the 2-party system, I’m not a fool.  It’s almost as old as our country.  We love to fall into an “us” vs. “them” mindset.  But that doesn’t mean that I have to identify with either party.  Instead, I want to evaluate each candidate individually.  I’ll never fill in the “vote straight Democrat” or “vote straight Republican” bubbles…even if all of my candidates I’m choosing to vote for are of the same party.

So why I think that we’re on the right path by separating ourselves from the Republican Party, I know that there must be something else that my generation of Christians is missing.  Each generation in the past had a flaw so obvious to other generations but that they were blind to.

What is ours?  Could it be our greediness in holding on to our great wealth?  Could it be our reliance on programs?  Could it be the idea that we can be followers of Christ apart from being a part of His body?

Whatever our blind spot is, the thought that we have one (and that I, individually, do too) humbles me.  May we always be teachable.

Taking Liberties with Liberty

If you don’t like something in the American culture at large, is it okay to say it? Fight it? Encourage lawmakers to restrict it?

If the issue is the treatment of animals, the emission of greenhouse gases, or the enforcement of immigration laws, the answer seems to be yes.

But what if the issue is moral? Limiting pornography distribution, the defense of the traditional family, or the ending of legal abortion?

The answer seems to be no.

I know we Americans pride ourselves on our freedom.  I’m thankful to live here, truly.  But when did our inalienable rights to “life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness” come to mean “you mind your own business and I do whatever I very well please” ?

I’m okay if that “whatever” is just a difference of opinion.  Or just stupid.  But when it is something harmful to others or trashes and distorts one of God’s good gifts, a line has been crossed.

Civil discussion encouraged.

Photo by Beverly & Pack